IRS Rev. Ruling 2023-2
Share
The IRS Deals a Big Blow to Working Families
Many middle-class families rely on irrevocable trust documents in their estate plans and for Medicaid planning as seniors age. These trusts have been a cornerstone of financial planning for decades, particularly for families looking to protect assets from the high costs of nursing home care and reduce estate taxes.
The primary reason to use irrevocable trust-owned assets is that, after five years, the assets are generally exempt from inclusion in the estate for death taxes and Medicaid (nursing home) qualification purposes. This rule has allowed families to safeguard their homes and other valuable assets while ensuring they meet eligibility requirements for Medicaid assistance.
However, a new IRS ruling—Rev. Ruling 2023-2—has significantly altered the landscape for families using irrevocable trusts. The ruling eliminates a key benefit that families have relied upon for decades, creating new challenges for estate planning, Medicaid qualification, and long-term financial security.
The Impact on Real Estate Ownership
One of the major issues with long-term real estate ownership is the likelihood of significant appreciation in the value of the asset. For example, consider a home purchased 40 years ago for $100,000. With an average annual appreciation rate of just 4%, the home would now be worth nearly $500,000. This kind of growth is common and represents a substantial portion of many families' wealth.
Under the previous rules, individuals who sold their primary residence while living there could take advantage of the Section 121 exclusion, which provides a $250,000 capital gain exemption for single homeowners and a $500,000 exemption for married couples. For a couple selling a $500,000 home, this exclusion typically meant no taxes were due on the sale.
However, when a home is transferred into an irrevocable trust, the ownership shifts from the individual to the trust. Trusts are not eligible for the Section 121 exclusion, so selling a home owned by a trust has always come with potential tax implications. In the past, this was not a significant issue because of a provision known as the step-up in basis.
The Step-Up in Basis
Before Rev. Ruling 2023-2, assets held in an irrevocable trust could still receive a step-up in basis upon the death of the trust's grantor. This step-up adjusted the cost basis of the asset to its fair market value at the time of the owner’s death. For example, if a home purchased for $100,000 was worth $500,000 at the time of the owner’s death, the step-up in basis allowed heirs to sell the property for $500,000 without incurring any capital gains tax.
This provision was a critical benefit for families. It ensured that significant appreciation in the value of assets, particularly real estate, did not result in an onerous tax burden for heirs. The step-up in basis was especially important for middle-class families, where a home often represents the majority of an estate's value.
The Changes Under Rev. Ruling 2023-2
With the implementation of Rev. Ruling 2023-2, the IRS has ruled that assets transferred to an irrevocable trust will no longer receive a step-up in basis. This change is because assets held in an irrevocable trust are not considered part of the decedent's taxable estate. Under current tax law, only assets included in the taxable estate are eligible for a step-up in basis.
This ruling has far-reaching implications for families who use irrevocable trusts to protect their assets. For instance, if a family transfers an elder’s home into an irrevocable trust to shield it from nursing home costs (which can exceed $400,000 on average), they may now face significant tax consequences when the home is eventually sold. Without the step-up in basis, heirs will have to pay capital gains taxes on the difference between the original purchase price and the sale price.
To make matters worse, trust tax rules are much more punitive than individual tax rates. Trusts reach the highest tax brackets at much lower income levels, which could result in an even higher tax burden for families who sell assets held in an irrevocable trust.
What Families Should Do Now
Given the changes brought by Rev. Ruling 2023-2, it is critical for families to revisit their estate plans, Medicaid plans, and home ownership arrangements. Here are some steps to consider:
-
Meet with an Estate Planning Attorney and Financial Advisor
The first step is to consult with professionals who can help assess the impact of the new ruling on your specific situation. An estate planning attorney can review your trust documents, while a financial advisor can provide insight into the tax implications and potential alternatives. -
Evaluate the Use of Irrevocable Trusts
Families should carefully weigh the benefits and drawbacks of using irrevocable trusts under the new rules. While these trusts can still protect assets from Medicaid spend-down requirements, the loss of the step-up in basis may outweigh the advantages in certain cases. -
Consider Alternatives for Asset Protection
Other strategies, such as gifting assets outright or using revocable trusts, may be more advantageous for some families. These options allow for greater flexibility and can preserve the step-up in basis, but they come with their own risks and considerations. -
Reassess Home Ownership Plans
If your family home is currently held in an irrevocable trust, it may be worth exploring options to remove it from the trust or restructure the trust to preserve tax benefits. This is particularly important for families who anticipate selling the home after the elder family member’s passing. -
Plan for Capital Gains Taxes
If removing assets from the trust is not feasible, families should plan for the potential capital gains tax liability. This may involve setting aside funds to cover the tax bill or exploring ways to minimize the taxable gain, such as through improvements to the property that can increase the cost basis.
Adapting to the New Rules
Rev. Ruling 2023-2 represents a significant shift in how irrevocable trusts are treated for tax purposes. For many middle-class families, the loss of the step-up in basis creates new challenges that require proactive planning and strategic adjustments. While the ruling poses obstacles, it also provides an opportunity to revisit and optimize estate and Medicaid planning strategies.
By staying informed and working closely with experienced professionals, families can navigate these changes and find solutions that protect their assets, minimize taxes, and secure their financial futures. The key is to act now, before these new rules create unnecessary hardships for you and your loved ones. With careful planning, it is still possible to achieve your financial and estate planning goals, even in light of this latest IRS ruling.